I did the same thing for my girlfriend for christmas 07. I bought her a new iPod and sent it to colorware and had it colored, and then I put this song on it.
Kid Theodore : I'm a moth http://www.kidtheodore.com/ Song number 4 on the website. Give it a listen
She pretty much melted, for real, the look on her face was priceless.
That song is really good. Im definitely going to download that one. And way to go with the girl, its nice to hear that at least some people treat them the way they should be.
I like Unwinding Cable Car - Anberlin Certainly a good one
And this is one I'm kinda into now More Than a Memory