Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="IWT" data-source="post: 1939503" data-attributes="member: 83420">An interesting debate, not seen here before as far as I know. Apple sells a &quot;song&quot; to me.&nbsp; Subsequently, Apple loses a lawsuit such that it can no longer sell that &quot;song&quot; in the future. But does that mean that it must, somehow, remove that song from my collection?&nbsp; Hard to imagine exactly how Apple could do that.&nbsp; Until that happened, I would still own that &quot;song&quot; and play it when and where I like. But if Apple was able to remove it from my collection, then there should be a refund. The real issue is:&nbsp; if I purchased that &quot;song&quot;, then do I still own it?&nbsp; If I don't, then must I &quot;return&quot; it somehow or promise to delete it from my Music library? If I do still &quot;own&quot; it, then does Apple not have the requirement to allow me to download it again should my library become corrupted?&nbsp; After all, my purchase from Apple was legitimate at the time.&nbsp; Or was my purchase retrospectively illegal?I wonder what Randy would say?Ian</blockquote>

[QUOTE="IWT, post: 1939503, member: 83420"] An interesting debate, not seen here before as far as I know. Apple sells a "song" to me. Subsequently, Apple loses a lawsuit such that it can no longer sell that "song" in the future. But does that mean that it must, somehow, remove that song from my collection? Hard to imagine exactly how Apple could do that. Until that happened, I would still own that "song" and play it when and where I like. But if Apple was able to remove it from my collection, then there should be a refund. The real issue is: if I purchased that "song", then do I still own it? If I don't, then must I "return" it somehow or promise to delete it from my Music library? If I do still "own" it, then does Apple not have the requirement to allow me to download it again should my library become corrupted? After all, my purchase from Apple was legitimate at the time. Or was my purchase retrospectively illegal? I wonder what Randy would say? Ian [/QUOTE]

Verification

Name this item. 🍎