Not my point.
This is not focused on the nano per se-- it's my own, personal way of reacting to mega-mega-mega-hype about anything.
If I am considering making a purchase of, say, a TV or a car, I want to know both positive and negative opinions about it, no matter how small those positive and negative opinions are. If all I hear is OHMYGODTHISISTHEMOSTAWESOMETHINGTHAT'SEVERCOMEOUTYOUGOTTAGETONEOHMYGODOHMYGODWHATAREYOUWAITINGFOR????? that makes me step back and say "Okay, wait a minute. I'm sure it's cool, but there has to be another side to this."
When I considered buying my original iPod, I was a PC user with a Rio MP3 player. I knew several people who had iPods and were members of what I like to call "The Breathless Corps" who had absolutely nothing even remotely negative to say about their iPods. It wasn't until I met a guy who had an iPod and said "Here's what you need to look for; you may not like iTunes at first, you may have a problem with your Firewire interface, but this feature is really cool, etc. etc." that I felt I had both sides to the story.
My point is merely that I am, by nature, a cautious person who tends to view mega-hype a detractor, not an drawing point.
The reality is that I already own a 15 GB 3G iPod and a 1 GB Shuffle, so my portable music device dance card is already full and I don't need another one. If anyone feels that the nano (or shuffle, or Creative Zen) fits their needs, it's not my place to question them-- this is just my approach to what works for me.