G
G-Dog
Guest
I'm a young graphic designer, and I currently use a G4 933 with 1.25 Gigs of RAM running Panther as my workstation. All my software are Adobe CS releases. The computer has been in it's current state since 2002, before I joined the company, and is painfully slow and unstable. The company budget allows us to replace this machine with a new computer soon, and there is a debate going on as to what we should get, another Mac or a Dell.
Let me explain the situation, as it's a bit...stupid. Our IT guys here at work won't touch this Mac. They are stuck in 1990, and believe my Mac is unable to access the company network and share files like PDF's and JPG's with PC's. As such, they won't give me a user name/PW to access the company shared drives while a simple Connect to Server command is all that's needed. These guys are old school Unix lovers to, making it even more strange.
The other designers here are also stuck in 1990, and believe all files made on an XP machine are totally incompatible with OS X (including txt, pdf, eps, and so on). They also still refer to PC's as IBM's, even though their Macs PowerPC CPU's are made by IBM.
So, I'm stuck in the middle. The obvious solution seems to be to wait for the new Power Mac Pro desktops (or whatever they will be called), and use bootcamp when needed. That way, Everybody is happy. However, that would mean I'm still using OS X for work, and I'm very weary of that.
I have been using Mac since OS 8 in design school. I've used every version (up to panther) since then. I also have an iBook at home that I've used for several years. I know how to use a Mac. I'm also an advanced PC user (you have to be if you're a PC gamer). I know the ins and outs of XP.
While I prefer the interface of OS X and it's software, the performance and stability has always been severally lacking. Every Mac I have ever used has been extremely crash happy. My company has paid Compucraft (the only Mac repair shop in town) over 3K this year alone fixing various hardware and software crashes . Is the new hardware, combined with the latest versions of OS X, more stable than Panther running on my hardware? I have to re-boot this Mac three or four times a day after software stops responding, starts crashing, or what have you. Pretty much whenever I switch software, like Photoshop to InDesign.
Another issue, we would have to re-buy all the graphics software if we went with a new Dell, and that's a huge amount of money.
Any thoughts? Please, no "Macs are totally more cooler than IBM DOS PC's because they are so much more cooler!!!11" posts. I want to hear from people that move high res images all day using current hardware/software. And please be honest. I've known Mac users who are so blinded by loyalty (like my college profs) they claim their software never crashes, only unexpectedly quits from time to time, which is the same thing.
Thanks.
BTW, here is an example of an expensive of repair on this mac. This is an actual invoice from Compucraft for an actual repair.
http://www.discreaderror.net/updates/blog/02-08-06/osxsucks.jpg
Let me explain the situation, as it's a bit...stupid. Our IT guys here at work won't touch this Mac. They are stuck in 1990, and believe my Mac is unable to access the company network and share files like PDF's and JPG's with PC's. As such, they won't give me a user name/PW to access the company shared drives while a simple Connect to Server command is all that's needed. These guys are old school Unix lovers to, making it even more strange.
The other designers here are also stuck in 1990, and believe all files made on an XP machine are totally incompatible with OS X (including txt, pdf, eps, and so on). They also still refer to PC's as IBM's, even though their Macs PowerPC CPU's are made by IBM.
So, I'm stuck in the middle. The obvious solution seems to be to wait for the new Power Mac Pro desktops (or whatever they will be called), and use bootcamp when needed. That way, Everybody is happy. However, that would mean I'm still using OS X for work, and I'm very weary of that.
I have been using Mac since OS 8 in design school. I've used every version (up to panther) since then. I also have an iBook at home that I've used for several years. I know how to use a Mac. I'm also an advanced PC user (you have to be if you're a PC gamer). I know the ins and outs of XP.
While I prefer the interface of OS X and it's software, the performance and stability has always been severally lacking. Every Mac I have ever used has been extremely crash happy. My company has paid Compucraft (the only Mac repair shop in town) over 3K this year alone fixing various hardware and software crashes . Is the new hardware, combined with the latest versions of OS X, more stable than Panther running on my hardware? I have to re-boot this Mac three or four times a day after software stops responding, starts crashing, or what have you. Pretty much whenever I switch software, like Photoshop to InDesign.
Another issue, we would have to re-buy all the graphics software if we went with a new Dell, and that's a huge amount of money.
Any thoughts? Please, no "Macs are totally more cooler than IBM DOS PC's because they are so much more cooler!!!11" posts. I want to hear from people that move high res images all day using current hardware/software. And please be honest. I've known Mac users who are so blinded by loyalty (like my college profs) they claim their software never crashes, only unexpectedly quits from time to time, which is the same thing.
Thanks.
BTW, here is an example of an expensive of repair on this mac. This is an actual invoice from Compucraft for an actual repair.
http://www.discreaderror.net/updates/blog/02-08-06/osxsucks.jpg