MacBook Pro with the fast 200 GB HD (7200 rpm)

I would like to know if the fast hard disk drive with 7200 rpm for the MacBook Pro brings any serious disadvantages.

I have heard of many negative experiences, from hardware troubles to even failures.

a 7200rpm would probably generate more heat and drain more power on the battery.

a4 abt said:

a 7200rpm would probably generate more heat and drain more power on the battery.

Click to expand...

i noticed niether of these with my 7k200.

battery power is identical to what my 5400 drive was. also, its cooler accoring to istat pro.

the above quote is a huge generalization in my opinion. power req vary from drive to drive, so you cant base what one drive uses versus another.

The 200Gb 7200 is great, better than expected. Disadvantages, what????

Badley said:

The 200Gb 7200 is great, better than expected. Disadvantages, what????

Click to expand...

thats what i said. the only disadvantge to buying a 200gb 7200 drive now is that a 320gb 5400 will be just as fast, and youll lose out bigtime on size.

there was a 250gb 5400 out when i bought my 200gb 7200, but it was 200+$. the hitachi i got for 140$