Should I buy the new Intel Imac or find an old one?

Joined
Jan 7, 2006
Messages
586
Reaction score
17
Points
18
Location
Lexington, KY
Your Mac's Specs
Unibody Macbook 2.0, Blackberry Bold (Good Riddance iPhone)
It's kinda weird because I was supposed to go with my mother this evening to Compusa to get her 20" imac. Well I just went to Apple's website and saw that they released the intel imacs. Looks like better specs for the same price. Anything we should be aware of? Any reason to go with a powerpc setup versus the new?
 
Joined
Dec 1, 2005
Messages
169
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Hi I had my imac for xmas, and i would plump for the new one. The only reason to go for the older one is if you plan on using legacy programs which really need the IBM chip and to be honest the gains in speed will probably mean that the new Imac will be able to more than cope.

I say go for the new or why not go for the old at a discounted price!
 
Joined
Nov 9, 2005
Messages
514
Reaction score
7
Points
18
Location
Northern VA
Your Mac's Specs
MacbookPro 15.4, 2.2ghz i7 (Late 2011), Macbook 1,1 1.83ghz CoreDuo
the software and games ive heard have some problems playing, you need to make sure they have the "Universal" tag on them to use with intel chips and the g chips. Search it on apple.com or macrumors.com for more info on it. Hate for you to get one and buy some stuff for it and it not work with new technology and older apps. Or everything could work. I kno with an iMAC G5 youll be fine, the iMac intel Duo...you may or may not have problems...its really iffy. personally im still holding out til i hear more on updates
 
Joined
Dec 1, 2005
Messages
169
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Hi there, personally i see no reason not to go for the new updated Intel chips. The version of tiger that ships on the Intel machines is native now to the intel system and I have heard of little to no issues with intel machines running everything. I have just ordered my new imac with the intel chips and i have no concerns over it running everything that i have installe don my current imac g5 isight.
 
Joined
Oct 10, 2004
Messages
10,345
Reaction score
597
Points
113
Location
Margaritaville
Your Mac's Specs
3.4 Ghz i7 MacBook Pro (2015), iPad Pro (2014), iPhone Xs Max. Apple TV 4K
The only caution I would add is that no one really knows how well PPC only apps are going to run under emulation. Apps like Office 2004 will run, how well they will run will remain to be seen. That being said though, everything is going to go to universal binaries, so almost all new or updated Mac software will be compatible.
 
Joined
Dec 22, 2005
Messages
131
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Location
Iowa
Your Mac's Specs
17" iMac G5
baggss said:
That being said though, everything is going to go to universal binaries, so almost all new or updated Mac software will be compatible.

Does this mean that even though I have a G5 iMac, software that comes out 5 years from now will still be able to work in my machine? Or will the trend in the future to have programs only compatible on the Intel machines?

I just bought the G5 iMac in December for Christmas, now I'm worried no software will be available for it in the near future.

Thanks -
 
Joined
Oct 10, 2004
Messages
10,345
Reaction score
597
Points
113
Location
Margaritaville
Your Mac's Specs
3.4 Ghz i7 MacBook Pro (2015), iPad Pro (2014), iPhone Xs Max. Apple TV 4K
You bring up a good point. Apple has not specifically said how long the Universal Binaries thing will last. At some point, they will drop support for the PPC, just like they did for the 68K Macs. The chance you take by buying a PPC based mac, or by owning a relatively new one, is that Apple will drop support before your ready or able to buy a new machine.

I personally have been eyeing the Quad G5 Macs, but am now facing the same issue. Do I buy now,and get the last Gen PPC Mac or do I wait and get an Intel Mac? One would reason that the replacement for the Quad G5 is going to have to be one **** of a Machine to match what is already out there.

OfficeSpace RULES!
 
Joined
Dec 22, 2005
Messages
131
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Location
Iowa
Your Mac's Specs
17" iMac G5
baggss said:
You bring up a good point. Apple has not specifically said how long the Universal Binaries thing will last. At some point, they will drop support for the PPC, just like they did for the 68K Macs.

Does anyone know how long the support for the 68K Macs continued after the platform change? I guess I'm trying to get a feel for how long they supported them in the past, before they dropped the 68K...
 
Joined
Dec 1, 2005
Messages
169
Reaction score
4
Points
18
HI there I believe that support for the old Motorola setups was in excess of 3 years. What i would say is that Apple computers normally have a far greater life span than your average PC. I would personally look to replace any computer I had every 2-3 years, I would not be overly concerned. As it is I had my Imac G5 in December also but due to the flexibility of my finance I will upgrade tot he Mactel version with no real problems, I have listed my G5 Imac on Ebay and it it is making almost the money I paid for it. I tihnk Apple have been more sensitive to recent Isight Imac owners by not selling the new Imac Intels at the same price point. By making the intel machines more expensive it does help the residules of the Isight edition somewhat!
 
Joined
Oct 10, 2004
Messages
10,345
Reaction score
597
Points
113
Location
Margaritaville
Your Mac's Specs
3.4 Ghz i7 MacBook Pro (2015), iPad Pro (2014), iPhone Xs Max. Apple TV 4K
I believe that Apple support for 68K Mac software continued up through OS9.2.2, and some 68K Apps will still in emulation on OSX. Apple officially dropped 68K support with OSX.
 
L

lil

Guest
The first PPC Macs were released in 1994 (Peformas, the consumer line.....), the 68K Macs were made in the form of the top flight Quadra and top end PowerBooks until 1995.

Mac OS 8.1 was the last 68K (68040 only) compatible release and that was 1998. Apple formally dropped support for the 68K Macs some time in 1999 or 2000 (for the last models).

Even so, the 68K emulator still resides in PPC Macs these days. Even so, I expect PPC Macs to have at least 3-4 years support still, and lets face it, they won't stop working when Apple drops support.

My IIfx here was released in 1990, runs System 7.5.3, a venerable 68030 at 40MHz and it still ticks on. In its the day the IIfx was the Power Mac Quad, these days it's a very quiet backwater but it still works and is still useful for basic stuff.

Vicky
 
J

j90jay

Guest
What should I do then?

I purchased an iMac G5 last week (!!), and at the time was blissfully unaware that the change to intel CPUs would be taking place SO soon. I bought an iMac G5 because I wanted a good, reliable machine that would last me for several year to come, now I may not be able to buy software for it in the future. As I am still within my 14-day money-back garuntee with the Apple store, I could upgrade relatively cheaply (shipping costs for the return, £60). Perhaps someone with a better understanding of Apple/hardware etc. than myself could tell me if they would recommend me upgrading?
 
L

lil

Guest
First of all, seriously, and no offence, scour the forums for hundreds of excellent responses to those exact questions.

If you are worried about you Mac becoming redundant in 1-2 years time, that would be foolhardy thinking; that won't happen. Jobs does a marvellous job at making everything sugar coated, but the estimates of the speed gains I think are deliberately misleading. It has been pointed out by others that one minute the PowerPC is where it is at - hammering the Intel processors, and now it's the other way around. Which means the truth lays in between somewhere.

In short, anything that is not intel native and that is most Mac software at present, will have to run on an emulator and that regardless of what Steve Jobs wants to say is going to be slower than your current G5 chip.

However please look at previous threads and use the search, these questions have been asked over and over and it would be a shame for you to miss out on the wisdom imparted in those posts.

Vicky
 
J

j90jay

Guest
Thanks for the advice lil, and no offence taken. I've been browsing through other threads, and getting some wise advise, but nevertheless, I'm still unsure of what to do. (Please forgive me, a newly converted mac user, trying to make sure I made the right choice - don't worry, whatever I decide I won't be going back to a PC!).

I know that there's absolutely no danger of my iMac becoming redundant in the next few years. I chose it precisely because I knew that it would be reliable and that I would be using it for several years to come, I'm concerned that I could purchase a similar computer for which I am garunteed to be able to purchase compatible software throughout the whole of it's life, in 3-4yrs time ppc compatible software won't be available/developed and I'll be left unable to install/upgrade anything until I can afford to buy a new machine - I was hoping my mac wouldbe around for longer than that.

On the other hand, if I buy into the mac-intel cpu's now, I face running slower, emulated software and then, I guess, having to purchase it all again when the intel native versions are released - why does it have to be so confusing?!?

I suppose the best solution is to, wait a couple of days, think about it some more, read even more threads/reviews etc. on the subject and decide then. But thanks for your help, and if anyone else wants to add their thoughts, please do (it might just help).
 
Joined
Nov 9, 2005
Messages
514
Reaction score
7
Points
18
Location
Northern VA
Your Mac's Specs
MacbookPro 15.4, 2.2ghz i7 (Late 2011), Macbook 1,1 1.83ghz CoreDuo
as what vicky said bout the years to come. im still sure that APPLE will keep Universal Software out for the next few years to come until they tottally have everyone switched and get all the bugs out. Im still very interested in seeing who has really tried to unleash the power of the intel mac.
 
J

Jewel

Guest
im just feeling a little OWNED that apple decided to release this intel iMacs after 2 weeks of me having a iMac G5
 
Joined
Dec 1, 2005
Messages
169
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Hi there, as I have said in previous posts, if you have bought a recent G5 imac such as myself simply drop it on Ebay and trade up to the Intel versions if that is what you want to do-obviously. They are still holding their money and one way to justify any loss you make is in terms of the added bonus of having the updated programs such as Ilife06 installed.

I love my G5 Imac and if it werent for my Finance agreement being flexible allowing me to upgrade at a very minor loss then I would be sticking with it and would be happy.

The way i would look at it is in the UK the intel based machines are more expensive than the G5 units all be it very slightly- so the price point of the older isight g5's is mantained- which is good for residule sales. But do not be worried about going for the newer setups. People on here should not be so discouraging of the new Intel setups. Only the real power applications will require Rossetta ( the PowerPc emulator ) to work and from industry rumblings I have heard that Office for example shows no sign of slow down and from an American friend at the expo he said that when he was demo'd an new Intel Imac running Indesign and Illustrator that it was very marginally quicker than his current G5 setup. Now factor into this that there will be Intel friendly universal versions released around March and the intel machines will (fingers crossed here) give a significant speed increase- this is theoretical obviously.

What i want to do is encourage people to go for the new machines if they want to, the point has been made that the G5 is a ruddy good chip and has taken care of Apple for some time now, but there is now a further choice.

This is the one thing we all should be thinking- wow we have an even bigger option now as Apple consumers and that is the best thing surely?????
 
J

Jewel

Guest
^yea..i just wanna try out the intel because i dont wanna go through the hassle selling my G5 and buying another.Also my time for return for just the restocking fee is up because i got it for christmas.Only if Apple allowed an upgrade for people that bought the iMac G5 but its ok.
 
W

wseefeld

Guest
I, too, bought my iMac G5 one week before the big announcement. Of course, I also find myself on the fence about taking it back and switching to Intel. It sounds like performance will be significantly better, and I know dual-processor machines are more responsive, in general. But I have some sort of newfound loyalty to what I believe is a beautiful architecture. The G5 iMac may go down in history as a nearly "perfect" computer for its time. It's a shame it had to be so short-lived.

I like the idea of staying on the G5, but I'm very worried about regretting it because of the rapid move to Intel. I don't want to be stuck with some "old" legacy computer that I can't even load current software on, less than one year after I shelled out some major bucks for it. I know technology is a cruel mistress, but that's just crazy!

If I stay on PPC, I hope the software development support lasts at least two full years. And if I switch, I hope the Intel platform turns out to be a stable one. I wish I could get a glimpse into how all of that is going to turn out before my 14-day return window expires!
 
Joined
Dec 22, 2005
Messages
131
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Location
Iowa
Your Mac's Specs
17" iMac G5
I am coming to terms with my G5 iMac. I ordered ours on December 13. Owning the last version of the G5 iMac allows me to use every Mac application currently out there (without and emulator) and the ability to watch how the Intel thing unfolds over the next few years.

It seems that new software developed now will have to be compatible with both PPC and Intel, and when support for the PPC machines comes to an end, I may be ready to upgrade again.

I am now at peace with my G5. aaaahhhhh.... :yinyang:
 

Shop Amazon


Shop for your Apple, Mac, iPhone and other computer products on Amazon.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
Top