Well...I've never stated my opinions on the two before so...here goes:
I own both systems. If I had to sum up my feelings into a one liner...I'd say "To Nintendo: Be worried...be very worried."
For the DS: I like the DS and it's attept to try to inovate handheld gaming. I link the DS's ability to use all the existing library of GB Advance games. I don't really get into the stylus stuff though I must say...I even find using the demo of Metroid counter intuitive...For me, it's just difficult to get used to. I don't like the current selection of DS games. In fact the only ones I have are Tiger Woods and Spiderman 2 (only because it had to be bought by my wife in a combo deal when it came out). Tiger Woods is ok...the stylus control of the swing is a pretty nice of the touchscreen...but Spiderman 2 just plain blows. I don't like how Nintendo has crippled the wireless ability of the handheld (can't use KAI to tunnel
). And to the people that think that Nintendo won't give up on the DS if and when they come out with a true successor to the GB Advance...one statement for ya - remeber Virtual Boy anyone? I certainly hope the DS doesn't go down that road. I've always been a Nintendo fan...and I love a few of their homegrown franchises (Metroid, Zelda, Mario, etc.) but I think they're treading on thin ice with their older fans. I think they've forgotten that there is a whole generation of gamers that have grown up playing on Nintendo systems...but that they have done just that...they've grown up...and they want grown up games.
For the PSP: Having this much gaming power in a handheld...Amazing. Screen...blows the doors off the two screens on a DS. The selection of games might be rehashes of old PS2 games...but I think that they are more fun for the older gamer in general. The ability to watch movies and listen to music on the system WILL BE a major factor in the handheld system market (I have a GBA Movie Player as well...but it's no contest). I'm a traveling professional and I guarantee you that the DS will stay home and the PSP will come with me when I travel. It just has more uses in one device. I have heard others saying that the PSP doesn't feel like a handheld...it feels like a console...IMHO that's a good thing...and slightly amazing in it's own right. I think the success of the PSP is only limited by Sony's arrogance. If they would open the market up by producing a reasonably priced UMD recorder (even for movies only), if they will allow the full video capabilities of the machine to be used by videos off the memory stick, if they will allow more and more internet play to come to fruition...the sky's the limit for the PSP. A few titles for the PSP would seal the deal almost. I could see EQ on the PSP, a good FF title, a GTA title, a good FPS...and it's bye bye birdie for the older crowd on a nintendo handheld.
JMTC