i just purchased the new summer 2009 15" MBP yesterday, and feel I have some important information that I've seen no one else mention.
First, I did a ton of research and reading before making my purchase. I new the unibody MBPs (and the 2009 revision) had "better" or "glossier" screens.
What no one told me is *how* different the glossy screen on the unibody MBPs are, compared to the glossy screen on previous generation MBPs.
I own a 15" fall 2007 MBP with glossy screen. It's beautiful, easy to read, non-distractive, and I can use it outside. It's screen is bright enough to use outside without issue. Unfortunately the keyboard and trackpad no longer work and requires repairs costing $500-$900.
My new 15" unibody MBP has mirror-like qualities. It's asinine. I'm in a daylight-lit room (no artificial lights and no direct sunlight) and I have to have the screen brightness all the way up so that my own mirror image will not distract from my reading.
I want very very badly to love and keep this laptop. Everything else about it is spectacular. But the reflectiveness really is a hindrance and a usability killer.
And to all those saying it's a personal preference... and to all those asking about "matte vs glossy"... Remember ***Not all glossy screens are equal!***
So when reading the forums, take into account that:
1) Many people haven't used both, but voice their opinion anyway
2) Many people are comparing based on a glossy screen from previous version or different laptop
If you like the glossy screen on the new unibody MBPs, then I commend you, and you're lucky, since you'll be able to keep it and be a happy user. For for the rest of us, I'm very disappointed...
Apple offers an anti-glare screen as an option for the 17" MBP. Readers, please ask Apple to include this option on the 15" line as well. The 17" MBP is not an option for many people, for various reasons including size, cost, etc.