ReiserFS

PMatos · Apr 3, 2008

Hello,

I've been using Linux for many years now but my department decided to give me a Macbook to play with. Most of my external Hdds are formatted ReiserFS which doesn't seem to be supported [leopard can't read them]. Is there a way to install support for ReiserFS or at least know which file systems Leopard supports so that I format them to one of these systems?

Cheers,

Paulo Matos

Juan Largo · Apr 3, 2008

I believe Leopard runs on hfs+ formatted partitions.

PMatos · Apr 3, 2008

Juan Largo said:
I believe Leopard runs on hfs+ formatted partitions.

But that doesn't say either if it is possible to add reiserfs support to leopard or which fs types are supported.

Juan Largo · Apr 3, 2008

PMatos said:
Hello,

Is there a way to install support for ReiserFS or at least know which file systems Leopard supports so that I format them to one of these systems?

I think my post was clear: Leopard supports hfs+. If you format the partition to hfs+, Leopard will support it. You can to it with Parted Magic Boot CD.

mac57 · Apr 3, 2008

Unfortunately, Macs do not support ReiserFS. I checked out MacFUSE to see if it might support it, but that is a no-go as well. I am afraid that you are out of luck wrt getting a Mac to directly support your ReiserFS hard drives. You may have to put them onto a Linux system and then access them from the Mac through the Linux box via sshfs or some such.

My understanding is that ReiserFS is falling out of favor even in the Linux world? I don't remember the exact reason, but I seem to recall that it is more "political" than technical. Anyway, for example, SuSE no longer defaults to ReiserFS, falling back to good 'ol ext3.

PMatos · Apr 3, 2008

Juan Largo said:
I think my post was clear: Leopard supports hfs+. If you format the partition to hfs+, Leopard will support it. You can to it with Parted Magic Boot CD.

So I would assume Leopard supports nothing else than hfs+ which is false.

PMatos · Apr 3, 2008

mac57 said:
Unfortunately, Macs do not support ReiserFS. I checked out MacFUSE to see if it might support it, but that is a no-go as well. I am afraid that you are out of luck wrt getting a Mac to directly support your ReiserFS hard drives. You may have to put them onto a Linux system and then access them from the Mac through the Linux box via sshfs or some such.

My understanding is that ReiserFS is falling out of favor even in the Linux world? I don't remember the exact reason, but I seem to recall that it is more "political" than technical. Anyway, for example, SuSE no longer defaults to ReiserFS, falling back to good 'ol ext3.

Thanks for reply, however, I've never read anything about ReiserFS going behind. SuSE might no longer support it but that's a distro and in my opinion, a *disgusting, horrible, hate it, all negative feelings* one. Linux still supports ReiserFS and I doubt it'll cut the support from either v3 or v4.

mathogre · Apr 3, 2008

mac57 said:
My understanding is that ReiserFS is falling out of favor even in the Linux world? I don't remember the exact reason, but I seem to recall that it is more "political" than technical. Anyway, for example, SuSE no longer defaults to ReiserFS, falling back to good 'ol ext3.

It has something to do with the fact that the original author is on trial for the murder of his wife.

http://www.google.com/search?q=reis...s=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a

PMatos · Apr 3, 2008

mathogre said:
It has something to do with the fact that the original author is on trial for the murder of his wife.

http://www.google.com/search?q=reis...s=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a

Thanks!

PMatos · Apr 4, 2008

Will it read Ext2 or Ext3?

Aptmunich · Apr 4, 2008

This page has some info:
http://www.kernelthread.com/mac/osx/arch_fs.html

(Check the bottom note)

PMatos · Apr 4, 2008

Aptmunich said:
This page has some info:
http://www.kernelthread.com/mac/osx/arch_fs.html

(Check the bottom note)

Thanks! On the other hand I can format it as HFS+ and I know that Linux reads that...

mac57 · Apr 4, 2008

PMatos said:
Thanks for reply, however, I've never read anything about ReiserFS going behind. SuSE might no longer support it but that's a distro and in my opinion, a *disgusting, horrible, hate it, all negative feelings* one. Linux still supports ReiserFS and I doubt it'll cut the support from either v3 or v4.

Wow, I feel exactly the opposite. SuSE remains a real favorite of mine. 9.3 was a standout - a bit slow, but a standout. 10.3, which I run now, is simply exceptional. Extremely fast to boot up, completely stable, very well supported, huge selection of app...

I use Arch Linux (which I call a "roll your own" Linux - you configure EVERYTHING by hand) and SuSE - SuSE is sort of the opposite of Arch in that everything is beautifully thought out and preconfigured. I am constantly amazed at how detailed and well thought out SuSE is.

Just my two cents.

PMatos · Apr 4, 2008

mac57 said:
Wow, I feel exactly the opposite. SuSE remains a real favorite of mine. 9.3 was a standout - a bit slow, but a standout. 10.3, which I run now, is simply exceptional. Extremely fast to boot up, completely stable, very well supported, huge selection of app...

I use Arch Linux (which I call a "roll your own" Linux - you configure EVERYTHING by hand) and SuSE - SuSE is sort of the opposite of Arch in that everything is beautifully thought out and preconfigured. I am constantly amazed at how detailed and well thought out SuSE is.

Just my two cents.

I am amazed at how polite you were in your reply [people usually tend to be much more agressive when it comes to defend their distro].

I don't know SuSE that well. Last time I tried SuSE was more than 5 years ago. I use Gentoo as my everyday distro. I tried Ubuntu lately which is very good but I am really used to Gentoo. Yesterday I got a laptop replacement from my department because my Gentoo laptop died. The replacement is a macbook. It's been hard to adapt. If I feel it is impossible, I'll install Gentoo on it!

However, I am interested in hearing how do you adapt, sync files, etc between your linux and mac life.

mac57 · Apr 4, 2008

Well, I have written a guide on that very topic! Check out my web site (www.Campbell-tx.net) and follow the links to my Linux To Mac Switcher's Guide. Let me know what you think.

PMatos · Apr 4, 2008

mac57 said:
Well, I have written a guide on that very topic! Check out my web site (www.Campbell-tx.net) and follow the links to my Linux To Mac Switcher's Guide. Let me know what you think.

It seems a very good guide... Given its a bit lenghty, I'll read it throughtly tomorrow.

Thanks!

bobtomay · Apr 4, 2008

Great pic mac 57 - the roadway at Windjammer Landing.

Love it - new desktop - thanks

mac57 · Apr 4, 2008

Thanks Tom, glad you liked it!

PMatos · Apr 7, 2008

mac57 said:
Well, I have written a guide on that very topic! Check out my web site (www.Campbell-tx.net) and follow the links to my Linux To Mac Switcher's Guide. Let me know what you think.

Thanks for the excellent guide. It is indeed quite good although I am having a hard time adapting.

Still, for the record, the project ext2fsx doesn't has full ext2 support for leopard...

I am stuck to HFS+ or FAT32. Let it be FAT32 then...