Mac Forums

Mac Forums (http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/)
-   OS X - Apps and Games (http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/os-x-apps-games/)
-   -   Office 2010 (WIN) vs. Office 2011 (Mac) (http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/os-x-apps-games/226416-office-2010-win-vs-office-2011-mac.html)

chomper 01-13-2011 01:55 PM

Office 2010 (WIN) vs. Office 2011 (Mac)
 
Hello,

I've just installed Office 2011 for Mac. To my great surprise, the ribbons in the programs are different from those of their Windows counterparts. But what IS really annoying is that in the Mac versions of Office programs, one cannot perform certain tasks without reverting to the use of menus! For example, I can insert a citation using the ribbon in Word, but I have to use a menu item to generate an index of figures - that's downright stupid. Is there a good resource somewhere on the internet that would describe these differences between Mac and Windows versions of Office? I haven't found anything yet and I need it badly... :(

Stanley 01-13-2011 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chomper (Post 1168990)
Hello,

I've just installed Office 2011 for Mac. To my great surprise, the ribbons in the programs are different from those of their Windows counterparts. But what IS really annoying is that in the Mac versions of Office programs, one cannot perform certain tasks without reverting to the use of menus! For example, I can insert a citation using the ribbon in Word, but I have to use a menu item to generate an index of figures - that's downright stupid. Is there a good resource somewhere on the internet that would describe these differences between Mac and Windows versions of Office? I haven't found anything yet and I need it badly... :(

Is solver still a Mac Excel issue in 2011? Did they add it or are there good add-ins? Thanks.

yogi 01-13-2011 03:14 PM

Get Started with Office for Mac 2011 | Office for Mac

See the "Learning Roadmap" on that page, for each app respectively. It isn't a great resource comparing Mac to Windows, but it's a good resource for getting a glimpse of how Office apps are organized on the Mac.

The issue with Office for Mac is that it's developed by an own, almost isolated Team at Microsoft. Their Approach is to make a version of Office that caters to the specific need of "Mac people" (= artsy-fartsy dudes who don't do "real" work) according to Microsoft. The better approach would be to just write a one-to-one copy of Windows Office in Cocoa. But they won't do that, will they?

technologist 01-13-2011 03:55 PM

Yes, you have to "revert" to the use of clearly-labeled, searchable menu commands instead of huge, abstract toolbar buttons.

It's true that Microsoft makes some odd decisions about how to organize Office, but the fundamental truth of it is that the Mac version of Office is different from the Windows version of Office because the Mac is different from Windows. If you're looking for a Windows interface, you bought the wrong type of computer.

yogi 01-13-2011 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by technologist (Post 1169062)
If you're looking for a Windows interface, you bought the wrong type of computer.

I don't think it would be fair to demand the Windows Office UI on the Mac, because as you said, a Mac is different and the Application should integrate with the OS to deliver a superior experience.

But I'm not asking for the UI, I think it would just be great if there were some level of coherence between Windows and Mac versions. The ribbon is a good innovation (and I'm all for UI innovation when it adds value), and all ribbon items are still accessible (and searchable) through the Menubar. But instead of copying the structure, they came up with a completely new structure, which has nothing to do with the Mac, but with rather bewildering assumptions on Microsoft's part that people using a Mac work differently.

There are details that are just unfathomable: Why is the Filter view on a Mac a "Black Glass" modal view and a regular dropdown on Windows? It goes on and on...

Stanley 01-13-2011 06:56 PM

What is the best office suite that is 100% or close to the same on Macs & PCs? Possibly Open Office or Libre Office?

chscag 01-13-2011 07:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stanley (Post 1169129)
What is the best office suite that is 100% or close to the same on Macs & PCs? Possibly Open Office or Libre Office?

None are 100% close. The closest you're going to get is by using MS Office.

There are definitely differences (as the other replies pointed out) but nothing IMO would make me switch to an inferior office suite which I consider the others to be.

Stanley 01-14-2011 11:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chscag (Post 1169133)
None are 100% close. The closest you're going to get is by using MS Office.

There are definitely differences (as the other replies pointed out) but nothing IMO would make me switch to an inferior office suite which I consider the others to be.

I thought there might be something pretty close.

Closest I can see across all platforms may be the web/cloud based options. Such as Google Docs and MS Live Skydrive/~Office. They should operate IDENTICALLY on Windows or Mac or ? machines if not for browser settings / peculiarities.

bazanders 01-14-2011 01:30 PM

Office 2011 on the mac just plain sucks, I cant believe Outlook wont even sync with ical, what a joke.
Very poor relative to the PC version

chscag 01-14-2011 01:42 PM

Keep in mind that Outlook 2011 for the Mac is a new application, version 1.0. You can not compare it to Outlook on the PC which has been a mainstay for years.

I don't use Outlook either on our Mac nor the PCs we own, however, Word, Excel, and Powerpoint work well, just as well as they do in Office 2010. As I mentioned above there are differences and Office 2011 can be improved, but what application can't?

technologist 01-14-2011 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bazanders (Post 1169508)
Office 2011 on the mac just plain sucks, I cant believe Outlook wont even sync with ical, what a joke.
Very poor relative to the PC version

Well, the PC version doesn't sync with iCal, either.

(Seriously...iCal or Outlook, pick one...there's no reason to use both.)

Stanley 01-14-2011 01:50 PM

Are there iCal plugins / addons? There are "solver" addons.

bazanders 01-14-2011 07:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by technologist (Post 1169515)
Well, the PC version doesn't sync with iCal, either.

(Seriously...iCal or Outlook, pick one...there's no reason to use both.)

The point is of course not only does it not sync ical but it wont sync with your phone therefore useless, just google outlook 2011 wont sync with phone or google and youll see what i mean

chscag 01-14-2011 09:02 PM

Entire thread moved here to OS X applications where it belongs. Does not belong in Switcher.

Gocho 06-01-2011 07:55 PM

I posted a thread elsewhere, but this touches on my question so I'll add it here as well:

Are there major FUNCTIONALITY differences between Office 2010 for Windows and office 2011 for Mac? I plan on installing Bootcamp regardless, so I'm debating between which version to eventually install.

For example, I believe that, for a time at least, macros were an issue with Office 2007 for Macs. Are there comparable issues with Office 2011?

Thanks.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:27 PM.

Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.