12-03-2011, 05:45 PM

I got my phone a month ago and it's great but I've been having to call everyone I call twice now bc they can't hear me the first time I call. It's on like 75% of the calls. I've looked this up and it seems A LOT of people are dealing with this with now acknowledgement from Apple yet. Now I was trying to make a call and speaker goes on before I even bring it to my ear and the person cannot hear me, so annoying. I couldn't even call tech support because they couldn't hear me.

I reset the phone after numerous failed tests and it worked fine but this shouldn't be happening to literally "the best phone on the planet". Do you think that this will be a software fix? or did Apple ship a bunch of bad proximity sensors with the 4S? A standard google search for the issue pulls up a lot of different people dealing with this issue but no nailed down fix. Anyone else dealing with this?

12-04-2011, 12:09 PM

I've noticed that, when taking a call from my wife at least, there's about a 3 second gap from the time I answer to when she can actually hear me. I doubt it's the proximity sensor because I usually just use the speakerphone. Whether or not it's a hardware or software issue, who knows. Wait for 5.1 to see if it fixes it. If not, start calling Apple.

12-04-2011, 02:53 PM

It's a little more involved than that, I've gotten the delayed call on my 4 before, just got used to it but this is more like the speaker in the receiver is disconnected for that call no matter what you do. Then it would do that and automatically goto speaker when making a call. So I'm on speaker and the button won't switch it off AND the person can't hear me. Thanks for the reply, sounds like your issue might just be routine calling stuff if it doesn't happen all the time.

Ever since I did a reset it works as it should but it's pretty troubling this early. I wish they would just address it and maybe there will be a software fix bc I really don't want to go back to the store and deal with it. Is the Genius Bar free?

12-04-2011, 05:47 PM

Interesting. My wife had this issue - on multiple occasions. I actually assumed it was related to her bluetooth - but interesting that this issue is surfacing elsewhere.

12-12-2011, 10:35 PM

Did you guys find a solution to the mentioned problem?? I was also having the same problem , please advice.

12-13-2011, 11:03 AM

When I got the total muted outgoing and only working in speaker problem I reset the phone and didn't have the problem for a few days but now it's popping up again where I have to call people twice for them to hear me. Try resetting, its a quick fix but hopefully Apple addresses this before my warranty runs out. I want to bring it in but I don't want to go through the trouble of transferring everything again.

12-17-2011, 03:50 AM

Have similar situation. Most of the time, audio is muted after dialing a number / holding the phone the right way. Audio always work fine when on speaker.

So, what works for me, is after dialing a number (speaker off), press the speaker on and right away press the same button again to turn it off. Audio will work right away, without having to use speaker only.

Geez, hope that wasn't confusing. Basically, dial the number, then tap the speaker icon twice, and then you'll instantly hear the ringing of the number dialed....

12-17-2011, 06:36 PM

Has anyone else got any solution to this?

I noticed it as well. As soon as I answer my phone, it has a 3 sec gap before caller can hear me talking and vice versa.

12-30-2011, 11:28 AM

My husband gifted each other iPhone 4S earlier this month and my iPhone worked just fine until two weeks ago. When he would call me, I could hear him but he could not hear me. When I called him, he could not hear me but I could hear him. When I turned the speaker, we could hear one another.

I, too, thought it was my chubby cheek hitting the mute icon at first but found out that was not the case.

Finally, after reading all the posts on recommended solutions, I decided to reset my iPhone 4S. Made outgoing and received incoming calls and thus far, all is okay. Will keep my fingers crossed!

Other than this, we STILL love our iPhone 4S.

01-04-2012, 03:23 PM

A week after resetting my iPhone 4S, my husband called me and I could hear him but he could not hear me; the mute was turned on automatically when I answered the call. This happened again and again. We called Apple Support and the gentleman asked me to press and hold down the off button a the top of my iPhone 4S for fifteen seconds. When I did as he instructed, now my husband can hear me. Still . . . I wonder how long will I be able to receive a call without my iPhone going mute automatically? I LOVE my iPhone but this is getting redicules. I hope Apple can prove to us "converted" customers that we were NOT wrong to buy iPhones as I am getting a $inking feeling that we may have made an expen$ive mistake.

01-05-2012, 03:03 AM

Apple is aware of the issue, but according to this article your "fix" may well be permanent. They are pretty obviously investigating and will fix it if your solution turns out not to be permanent.

Report: some iPhone 4S units may have audio issues on calls | Electronista

01-05-2012, 10:47 AM

Glad to read that Apple is aware of the problem because the issue has not been "fixed" or resolved: having the same problem of muting when I answer the call. I performed a 15 sec. hard shutdown again and the other person I called can then hear me. Next step: remove the Otter Box cover and try to make calls on my iPhone 4S.

01-05-2012, 12:04 PM

Originally Posted by hro1957

Glad to read that Apple is aware of the problem because the issue has not been "fixed" or resolved: having the same problem of muting when I answer the call. I performed a 15 sec. hard shutdown again and the other person I called can then hear me. Next step: remove the Otter Box cover and try to make calls on my iPhone 4S.

Removing the Otter Box will have zero impact on this.

01-05-2012, 12:23 PM

Great . . . A separate HD anti-glare film skin was placed over the iPhone 4S by the Apple technician when we purchased our iPhones. Then we walked over to the AT&T store and purchased the Otter Box Defender that also has a hard clear skin on it as well. Could there be an issue / problem having TWO clear skin covers? Apple recommended removing the iPhone 4S from the Otter Box and see what happens. Could it be possible that cold weather that condensation between the skins affects the iPhone?

01-05-2012, 01:56 PM

Originally Posted by hro1957

Great . . . A separate HD anti-glare film skin was placed over the iPhone 4S by the Apple technician when we purchased our iPhones. Then we walked over to the AT&T store and purchased the Otter Box Defender that also has a hard clear skin on it as well. Could there be an issue / problem having TWO clear skin covers? Apple recommended removing the iPhone 4S from the Otter Box and see what happens. Could it be possible that cold weather that condensation between the skins affects the iPhone?

I don't use a screen protector and have had the problem with and without a case. If there is a condensation issue, you'd be having far bigger issues than this.