Mac Forums

Mac Forums (http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/)
-   Apple Notebooks (http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/apple-notebooks/)
-   -   Will it hold up ?? (http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/apple-notebooks/6440-will-hold-up.html)

xr600 05-12-2004 05:53 PM

Will it hold up ??
 
Hi...

I'm thinking of replacing my 12" ibook with a 15.2" PB, because of the bigger screen... however, I am a bit concerned if it will withstand the daily routines. I am a student, whitch mean that the book will be spending quite a bit of time in my backpack, and at times even with weight on top of it !, my ibook seems to deal with this just fine, but what about the PB ??... the feel of the machine tells me that it is a bit more fragile than the ibook, but is it actually so ??. And how about the surface (cosmetics), is it as durable as the ibook ?? :).

BTW, the machine I'm looking at is the 1.25 Ghz... way too expensive for my budget... hmmm...

Regards.

Torben.

TylerMoney 05-12-2004 06:05 PM

the powerbooks are extremely durable....though because there is more surface space, and more weight...I would just make sure you got some sort of sleeve for your computer...or invest in a new backpack made for 15"laptops...that way you have the best of both worlds.....

Strider 05-13-2004 06:15 PM

Definately get a sleeve if ur getting a PB. Or if u buy a brenthaven backpack, u get a built-in sleeve that u can use seperately, and no worries about durability too.

trpnmonkey41 05-13-2004 06:22 PM

and if there will be weight on it be sure to get a keyboard cover to use when the lid is closed

witeshark 05-13-2004 06:47 PM

I'm sure it will hold up fine. I've seen some roughed just a bit without flinching :)

xr600 05-14-2004 05:44 PM

ThanX for the replies...
 
... Guess I'll be going for it then ;).

One last thing... has anyone got hands on experience as to how much less uptime I should expect from the PB compared to my 12" ibook G4 ??. I mean, if I squeeze the ibook I can get around 6-6:30 h. from it on a charge... what should I expect from a 1.25 PB ?? :).

Regards.

Torben.

TylerMoney 05-14-2004 06:13 PM

well, it all depends....I don't know if the newest batteries are better or not...but I get around 2.5-4.5 hrs on mine, depending on use....I'd say an average of 3.5hrs...which is still really good for a laptop...and people have been talking about getting much more than that out of their machines....

Osiris22x 05-15-2004 03:06 AM

The iBook is much more durable and sturdy than the Powerbook. Apple said they designed the iBook for students and the Powerbook for professionals. In testing, they dropped the iBook, stuck it in a freezer, had a kid jump his skateboard off of it, and then had several kids carry it around for a day in their backpacks and beat the snot out of it. In the end, the iBook was just fine with no damage.

Next up was the Powerbook. They dropped it, and it broke. End of test.

I have a Powerbook and I love it...but if you get one, get a case for it. Don't just stick it unprotected into your bag. ;)

xr600 05-15-2004 08:54 AM

Useful info :)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris22x
The iBook is much more durable and sturdy than the Powerbook. Apple said they designed the iBook for students and the Powerbook for professionals. In testing, they dropped the iBook, stuck it in a freezer, had a kid jump his skateboard off of it, and then had several kids carry it around for a day in their backpacks and beat the snot out of it. In the end, the iBook was just fine with no damage.

Next up was the Powerbook. They dropped it, and it broke. End of test.

I have a Powerbook and I love it...but if you get one, get a case for it. Don't just stick it unprotected into your bag. ;)

What exactly do you mean by a case ?, a "flightcase" type of thing, og just a "scratchbag" ?...

I must admit that I like my ibook alot, and am a bit doubtful about if the Powerbook is right for me. The major drawbacks on my G4 ibook (the reason I'm considering the PB), are mainly the keyboard (too "loose", I tend to type "double letters"), the screensize (I know about the 14" ibook, but think it's too big), and the fact that I can't put put more than 640 mb, RAM in it (means that if I wan't to run e.g. VPC on it, it gets sloooow). '

Still I'm not quite sure if these arguments are good enough for a "switch"... I do take good care of my laptops, but the fact is that I'm going to be bicycling with the thing in my backpack 25-30 km. just about every day, and I am afraid that the PB will end up a mess in a months time...

Regards.

Torben.

PS. Has anyone got any experience as to if the PB is really picky with the RAM ??. I considered moving the 512 mb. from my ibook the the PB, and I can't remember if the darn thing is pc 2100, or 2700...

prozach1576 05-15-2004 11:36 AM

Get a Booqbag. I just got one. It has a backpack with a 15" PB compartment, and came with a standalone sleeve that also fits in that compartment. Excellent protection.

Strider 05-15-2004 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xr600
What exactly do you mean by a case ?, a "flightcase" type of thing, og just a "scratchbag" ?...

No, a proper sturdy backpack/carry case like the Brenthaven one. Go have a look at their website.


Quote:

Originally Posted by xr600
Has anyone got any experience as to if the PB is really picky with the RAM ??. I considered moving the 512 mb. from my ibook the the PB, and I can't remember if the darn thing is pc 2100, or 2700...

Powerbook is PC2700.

Osiris22x 05-16-2004 05:26 AM

Well I bought myself a nice thick case from the Mac Store that fits nicely in my bag. The next day I had to slam on the brakes in my car, and my laptop hit the dash board at about 40 mph. I quickly pulled it out to see what the damage was, and it didn't have a scratch on it. Definitely don't get a thin case, you need something with cushioning.

As for RAM, I've put strictly Corsair VR PC2700 in my Powerbooks and have had perfect results. Keep in mind that you need to get RAM that has the correct timing and non-parity specifications. If the RAM's speed doesn't match the system, that's not a problem, it just might not perform the best.



Quote:

Originally Posted by xr600
What exactly do you mean by a case ?, a "flightcase" type of thing, og just a "scratchbag" ?...

I must admit that I like my ibook alot, and am a bit doubtful about if the Powerbook is right for me. The major drawbacks on my G4 ibook (the reason I'm considering the PB), are mainly the keyboard (too "loose", I tend to type "double letters"), the screensize (I know about the 14" ibook, but think it's too big), and the fact that I can't put put more than 640 mb, RAM in it (means that if I wan't to run e.g. VPC on it, it gets sloooow). '

Still I'm not quite sure if these arguments are good enough for a "switch"... I do take good care of my laptops, but the fact is that I'm going to be bicycling with the thing in my backpack 25-30 km. just about every day, and I am afraid that the PB will end up a mess in a months time...

Regards.

Torben.

PS. Has anyone got any experience as to if the PB is really picky with the RAM ??. I considered moving the 512 mb. from my ibook the the PB, and I can't remember if the darn thing is pc 2100, or 2700...


lzasitko 05-16-2004 11:04 AM

Booq
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by prozach1576
Get a Booqbag. I just got one. It has a backpack with a 15" PB compartment, and came with a standalone sleeve that also fits in that compartment. Excellent protection.

I have a Booq Powersleeve coming for my 12" PowerBook. Looks well padded. When I bought the computer they gave me a Mareware Sportfolio II but it does not have a lot of padding, better then none but I want something that is going to really protect it. Ripoff makes a case for my Newton 2100 and it is very well made and looks almost new after 5 years use. The padding in it has certainly helped a lot. The Booq Sleeve looks similar and better padding.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.