Results 1 to 8 of 8
  1. #1
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    RGertner's Avatar
    Member Since
    May 06, 2005
    Location
    Poughquag, NY
    Posts
    155
    Specs:
    IBM PCjr, 4.77 MHz Intel 8088, 640K RAM, 5.25" Floppy, Basic Cartridge, PC DOS 2.11
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    On May 5th I purchased a 17" 2.0 Ghz iMac G5 from my local Apple store, and was very happy with it, but had a few hardware issues with the video cutting out. This had been occuring from day 1 of owning the iMac. Also, one of the first things I noticed about the iMac was that it was very very loud and my fans were always coming on, even from just opening a few applications such as iChat, Mail, and Safari and when I would rip on of my CD's into itunes, it was so loud it sounded like an airplain on my desk. Now, I have been using and IBM Thinkpad for the past 8+ years, and my latest one (T30) is rather loud when I have it in my docking station, so I am somewhat used to less than quiet systems.

    Well today I had had enough today with the hardware failures and exchanged my 17" iMac for a new one at the applestore, but instead of getting another 17" I picked up a 20" since they had them in stock.

    As soon as I powered the unit up I noticed that the 20" monitor is so much nicer than the 17". While I haven't looked at the specs beyond the resolution, the 20" seems to have a much better viewing angle. Also, this unit is whisper quiet. Both mine and my wife's cousin's iMac (purchased same model, the same day) are equally loud.

    Just my observations, but just on the noise alone I would have purchased the 20" if I knew it ahead of time.

    Thanks,
    Ray

  2. #2
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    donnation25's Avatar
    Member Since
    Feb 18, 2005
    Posts
    120
    Specs:
    20" iMac G5 1GB RAM Superdrive; 12" powerbook 512mb RAM G4 Superdrive
    I noticed the exact same thing. I had the 1.8ghz 17" model but upgraded to the new 20" model and noticed a big difference in the noise. The 20" is much quieter and I also think the monitor looks better as well.

  3. #3
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac

    Member Since
    Jan 27, 2005
    Location
    Maidenhead, UK
    Posts
    423
    Specs:
    20" intel iMac, 15" MBP, 3 X 13.3" MB (family etc), G4 tower, 12" G4 PowerBook, iBook G4, 20" iMacG5
    The 20" is beautiful, i love it sooo much!
    Alex

  4. #4
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    iWhat's Avatar
    Member Since
    Nov 11, 2004
    Location
    Toledo, Ohio
    Posts
    5,736
    Specs:
    Macbook, iMac G5, iPad, iPhone 4, iPod (MANY)!
    I got the 20" iMac G5, and I just love it. I can't remember what the 17" looks like in person, but I do see pictures, and it looks so little for some reason in comparison to the 20". I'm glad you like the 20" better. :cool:

  5. #5
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    RGertner's Avatar
    Member Since
    May 06, 2005
    Location
    Poughquag, NY
    Posts
    155
    Specs:
    IBM PCjr, 4.77 MHz Intel 8088, 640K RAM, 5.25" Floppy, Basic Cartridge, PC DOS 2.11
    While, the Monitor is definately bigger/nicer on the 20", really the big item that I noticed was the sound. Why is the 17" so loud when the 20" is so quiet?

    Thanks,
    Ray

  6. #6
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    bassplayrr's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 14, 2005
    Location
    San Fransisco Bay Area, CA, USA
    Posts
    500
    Specs:
    20" G5 iMac; 14.1" G4 iBook; 60Gig iPod Video
    Quote Originally Posted by RGertner
    While, the Monitor is definately bigger/nicer on the 20", really the big item that I noticed was the sound. Why is the 17" so loud when the 20" is so quiet?

    Thanks,
    Ray

    I'm really not sure, but the way I see it, the 20" is about 25% thicker and larger in all dimensions as well. So, I think that extra room allows for just enough of an increase in the computer's ability to cool that the fans are required to spin up less frequently. More rooms for air to cool the computer through convection = less need for the fans to spin into the higher and louder RPMs.

    -Chris

  7. #7
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    iWhat's Avatar
    Member Since
    Nov 11, 2004
    Location
    Toledo, Ohio
    Posts
    5,736
    Specs:
    Macbook, iMac G5, iPad, iPhone 4, iPod (MANY)!
    Quote Originally Posted by RGertner
    While, the Monitor is definately bigger/nicer on the 20", really the big item that I noticed was the sound. Why is the 17" so loud when the 20" is so quiet?

    Thanks,
    Ray
    I'm think that the confines of the 17" iMac might be a little more closed in, when the confines of the 20" iMac might be a little more spacious allowing more air flow. But that is only if you are talking about the fan issues of course.

  8. #8
    17" iMac vs. 20" iMac
    RGertner's Avatar
    Member Since
    May 06, 2005
    Location
    Poughquag, NY
    Posts
    155
    Specs:
    IBM PCjr, 4.77 MHz Intel 8088, 640K RAM, 5.25" Floppy, Basic Cartridge, PC DOS 2.11
    I have to take back some of what I said. Today I purchased a 17" iMac for my Mom (yup switched another person)...

    Anyway, the difference in noise between my 20" and her 17" (1.8Ghz w/Combo Drive) was very little. Yes, my 20" is a tad more quiet, but nothing like the 17" (2.0Ghz w/Super Drive) that I had. I imported a few CD's for her, setup her email and the system never got loud like my original 17" So I have to say, that I guess my problem was an abnormality.

    Thanks,
    Ray

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Ordered a "data doubler" kit for 21.5" iMac...
    By Lifeisabeach in forum Apple Desktops
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 08-05-2012, 02:45 PM
  2. Does a 17" imac g5 logic board fit a 20" imac g5?
    By 568129 in forum Apple Desktops
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 12-06-2011, 02:13 PM
  3. iMac 21.5" 3.33mhz - Memory Upgrade "Issue"
    By flypaper in forum Apple Desktops
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 05-09-2011, 10:09 PM
  4. Intermittent "whir click" sound on L speaker 27" iMac
    By Colininla in forum Apple Desktops
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 09-04-2010, 04:10 PM
  5. "Successfully" replaced HDD in 20" iMac 5.1, now no sound.
    By dcharlesworth in forum Apple Desktops
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 08-31-2010, 10:54 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •