Are these good skins? Other skin recommendations?

http://www.decalgirl.com/browse.cfm/2,249.htm

Has anyone tried these? They look pretty good, but I don't like that they don't cover the sides. I'm pretty much just looking for a plain black and I like the thin vinyl skins because they don't add any size to it.

I was thinking of the rubber incase protector, but I've read dust and dirt collects in the edges and scratches the phone.

Anyway, any comments on either of these or other recommendations would be appreciated.

I can't comment on the decalgirl but they do look pretty nice. The rubber incase protector I have tried and don't recommend it because of dirt/dust collection.

you could try GelaSkins

I'm not a big fan of skins. But some of those look pretty cool.

I have the incase rubber case for my iPhone and it does just fine. I don't have it on all the time, I think it makes it look ugly.

sanity1082 said:

you could try GelaSkins

Click to expand...

Those are nice, but same problem as decalgirl, they don't cover the sides. I guess that would be too tough without forming the vinyl somehow.

EuphLlama said:

I have the incase rubber case for my iPhone and it does just fine. I don't have it on all the time, I think it makes it look ugly.

Click to expand...

That's my other problem with the incase. I think I could be diligent in taking it off and cleaning to avoid the dirt issue, but it just doesn't look very good to me.

I guess you just can't have it all . . .

The Gelaskins are good, but they hide the beauty of your iPod. What about a clear skin and a sock or pouch?